Weblog Tools Collection

22 Comments | Leave a comment | Comments RSS

1. 

   Damn, my blog doesn’t have that many comments. Does that mean I’m broken? Well, my blog doesn’t really need comments, because I’m not always talking to people. Is it wrong to talk to yourself and expect no one to answer?

   [Reply]

   

   Jacob, it is nice that you use the blog thing to talk to yourself and don’t care about comments. However because your blog is public, others are bound to read the posts. Because we are all HUMAN beings and have similar problems and solutions, we can always gain from each other even if neither party aims for it.

   My problem with comments is the same as in forums, only if a thread is hot would it entice people to participate so in a sense the two things feed off each other. Any one who can break this problem would certainly not be broken. In fact blogs with comments are broken because they distract the participant from a more relevant post simply by being hot as opposed to relevant.

   [Reply]

   

   I’ve probably not made it clear - I meant a comment facility, not comments themselves.

   [Reply]

   
   Paul Bradshaw (4 comments.)

   September 15th, 2008 at 3:52 am

   
   amolpatil2k

   September 7th, 2008 at 2:45 pm

   Jacob Santos — 09/6/2008 @ 7:31 pm
2. 

   Game over at #1: “Blogging is not ‘writing a blog’. Blogging is linking and commenting. Any writing is a bonus.”

   Content is a *bonus*? By that standard, every splog in the world is better than any well-written, carefully thought-out genuine blog. At least they were courteous enough to make that the first thing on the list. It saves the time that would have been wasted reading further.

   [Reply]

   

   One more proof that mainstream media journalists still do not understand blogging. The guy’s banner gives me goose bumps.

   [Reply]

   

   Thanks Connie - was never entirely comfortable with it myself, and will probably change it now. One question: although I think I know what annoys you about the banner, would like to hear you put it into words (PS: I wouldn’t say I’m a “mainstream media journalist” - I’m an educator)

   [Reply]

   

   It hard-selling. In advertising, when a product needs an extraordinary push, it means it lacks in substance and cannot, therefore, succeed just by its own worth. That might not be so in your case but that banner surely gives that impression.

   Re I wouldn’t say I’m a “mainstream media journalist”

   Then, you really need to get rid of that banner.

   [Reply]

   
   Connie (3 comments.)

   September 15th, 2008 at 6:32 am

   
   Paul Bradshaw (4 comments.)

   September 15th, 2008 at 3:51 am

   
   Connie (3 comments.)

   September 7th, 2008 at 12:20 pm

   

   Metta, what I was trying to do was highlight that just exporting your traditional column onto the web is not blogging. You need to link and post comments to truly be ‘blogging’. Content helps, though - see #3.

   [Reply]

   

   I continue to be amazed by the devaluation of writing, plain and simple - and you just did it again. So I guess the question is this: Do you consider someone who only comments (and say, posts relevant links to other people’s blogs in their comments) to be blogging? Your language strongly suggests it when you say content is “a bonus” and that it “helps.”

   [Reply]

   
   Metta (2 comments.)

   September 15th, 2008 at 10:01 am

   
   Paul Bradshaw (4 comments.)

   September 15th, 2008 at 3:55 am

   Metta (2 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 8:14 pm
3. 

   I cant agree that a blog without comments is broken…Not every blog needs comments to be successful…A blog without traffic is broken, thats about it…A blog with traffic is successful even if it has no comments at all…I have started sites which have reached an Alexa ranking of around 20,000 and only had maybe a total of 100 comments within 3,000+ posts….Traffic equals revenue, no comments…You could have 46463463 comments but they could all be from the same people.

   [Reply]

   Joe (1 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 8:20 pm
4. 

   Jacob,

   Well if you start leaving your URL in the comments, you might start getting more comments eventually It’s a good practice to do, so people know who you are and where to find you

   [Reply]

   Jonathan Dingman (7 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 9:20 pm
5. 

   If a lack of comments truly does mean that a blog is broken, I need help. Could some of you kind souls try to put Humpty-Dumpty back together again?

   [Reply]

   Crawford Harris (3 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 9:37 pm
6. 

   “Google is the biggest popularity contest.”
   So true, so true, and we are all trying to win page 1!

   [Reply]

   ~Kat~ (1 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 10:14 pm
7. 

   I run a blog aound my circus project in Kenya and it’s mostly an information center for people who want to know upcoming event and where we are in the project… I don’t have many comments but that’s ok,because that’s not my goal…And visitors don’t even expect comment… One thing I learned blogging is give the content the best place…

   [Reply]

   Nathan Martin (1 comments.) — 09/6/2008 @ 10:47 pm
8. 

   One thing I’ve learned about blogging is that SEO seems like a bunch of crap. Seems to me like all you have to do is pick a niche, create relevant content for that niche and in doing so, you will naturally write keywords specific to that niche and the SEO aspects will take care of themselves. A whole industry created around common sense?

   [Reply]

   Jeff Chandler (260 comments.) — 09/7/2008 @ 5:42 am
9. 

   1. Since I primarily blog to hush the voices in my head *heh* any readership/comments my blog experiences are gravy.

   2. Blogs without gravy aren’t as juicy as blogs with gravy. Preferably sausage gravy with biscuits.

   [Reply]

   David (1 comments.) — 09/7/2008 @ 9:36 am
10. 

    @Crawford Harris “”… … Could some of you kind souls … …”"
    I tried to. I found some posts interesting. Then I discovered that I would have to _register_ at your site before I’d be able to leave a comment!

    If this was an accident, go and check under Settings(General) within your blog’s WP Dashboard for the ‘Users must be registered and logged in to comment’ option. Untick it. Click on Save Changes.

    If you meant to leave this on as some sort of anti-spam feature, you are most likely stopping 99% of people from leaving a comment. Perhaps consider making sure the Akismet plugin is up to date, enabled, and maybe add something like the Bad Behavior plugin as well.

    Hope you don’t mind the advice.

    [Reply]

    

    I do appreciate your comments. Being new to blogging I was afraid that the nature of my site might bring out the worst. Oh me of little faith. I will give opening up a try.

    [Reply]

    
    Crawford Harris (3 comments.)

    September 7th, 2008 at 4:46 pm

    

    Well, I took your advice. Check out my site and see what it got me. Naw, it wasn’t abusive but it did bring out a crazy.

    [Reply]

    

    Happy to see things open over there now As for the crazies, it looks as though you’re a better judge in that area than me. If you ever find yourself over run by the typing-capable loonies, don’t forget you can make every comment go through moderation, by turning off the option of having commenters auto-allowed once one comment has been approved by you.
    Anyway, we’re in danger of severely taking this comment off topic, so I’ll zip it for now.

    PS Apologies to the post writer for going off topic and failing to notice the ‘reply’ button before for comments

    [Reply]

    
    ChrisM (10 comments.)

    September 7th, 2008 at 6:56 pm

    
    Crawford Harris (3 comments.)

    September 7th, 2008 at 5:45 pm

    ChrisM (10 comments.) — 09/7/2008 @ 4:10 pm
11. 

    The nice thing about lists like this is that even if you don’t agree, there are so many points (100, not 1000) that some of them are bound to make you consider something you hadn’t before, and let you expand your blog in new directions.

    Although with points like “27. I seem to like linking on verbs” make me think the author would have been better off vetting the list somewhat.

    [Reply]

    Emanuel Nordrum (3 comments.) — 09/8/2008 @ 5:44 am
12. 

    Thanks for the point about multi authored blogs - if you know of a template that does include the author’s name in posts, and allows you to have a feed just from them, would appreciate it - I’ve wanted one for a while.

    [Reply]

    Paul Bradshaw (4 comments.) — 09/15/2008 @ 3:20 am

Leave a comment